Your membership has expired

The payment for your account couldn't be processed or you've canceled your account with us.

Re-activate

    Talking Cars 410: Driving the Rivian R1S SUV

    Plus, we help an audience member choose a more fuel-efficient SUV with a hearty towing capacity to replace his Toyota Highlander

    Main theme: In this episode, we give our first driving impressions of the all-electric Rivian R1S. It’s based on the same mechanicals as the R1T pickup truck we’ve already tested, except the R1S is a three-row SUV. Our discussion involves the similarities and differences with the R1T, as well as how the R1S compares with other larger EV SUVs on the market, such as the Tesla Model X

    Our panel wades into what it’s like to floor the accelerator pedal on an 835-hp, all-wheel-drive SUV—the answer is that it’s thrilling! We also analyze the R1S’ ride and handling and debate the usefulness of its interior gimmicks. And we pose the question: “Of all things that an automaker might copy from Tesla, why choose the controls?” Rivian’s uber-touchscreen-based infotainment setup, which eschews most physical controls, is a near-clone of Tesla. And, as with Tesla models, the result is driver distraction and lots of frustration behind the wheel of the R1S.

    Audience Question
    I want to replace my 2013 Toyota Highlander with an SUV that is more fuel-efficient yet can still tow at least 5,000 pounds, but I’m finding the search difficult. Does such a vehicle exist?

    Talking Cars Episode 410 panel
    "Talking Cars" panelists Mike Monticello, Joe Veselak, and Jake Fisher.

    Photo: Consumer Reports Photo: Consumer Reports

    As with other “Talking Cars With Consumer Reports” episodes, this one is available free through Apple Podcasts. (Subscribe to the audio or video.) You’ll also find the audio on Spotify (log-in required) and video on YouTube.

    Have a Question?

    We’d love to include it in a future show. Upload your video questions to our Dropbox folder. Please send high-definition (1920x1080) MP4 video files with high-quality audio. Or send an iMessage question to our TalkingCars@icloud.com account.

    Talking Cars Archive

    Browse the complete podcast archive for past shows.


    Mike Monticello

    Mike Monticello is the manager of road tests and reviews for the autos team at Consumer Reports. He has been with CR since 2016. Mike has been evaluating and writing about cars for nearly 25 years, having previously worked at Road & Track magazine and Edmunds.com. On the weekends, he usually switches from four wheels to two, riding one of his mountain bikes or motorcycles. Follow him on Twitter @MikeMonticello.